Hey guys,
I've had this thought on my mind recently, and maybe this is a strange way to say it but... have you ever wondered where to draw the line between compassion and stupidity?
The other night I was walking downtown with a couple of friends (both female) when we were approached by a man in his mid 30's. He was holding a cell phone in one hand and leading a small child with the other.
He stepped up to us as we were passing by on the sidewalk and said, "Excuse me, but could I get you ladies to help me? My son and I were just..."
At this point, I had already stopped. I was about to ask him what was wrong, how could I help, was he okay? etc. But my friend kept walking, brushing him off and muttering, "No."
Immediately, I realized how sketchy it was that this guy just happened to ask three teenage girls for help on a dark sidewalk in the middle of the city at night. That's sketchy right? I held on to that thought as we passed him and he began to call after us, specifically to my friend who had first said no.
"Oh that's bad. That's just bad. You're a bad lady. You're ugly too!"
Once we reached the parking garage and were in the car, I told my friend what my thought process had been, how it was only after seeing her reaction that her immediate conclusion even occurred to me. She made it clear that she did not regret for a moment walking past that guy. However, it's been several days since this all happened and it's still nagging at me.
The question I'm asking myself is, does this make me more compassionate than my friend, or simply more stupid? Can compassion impair a person's ability to make sound judgements? And if so, is it more important to be compassionate or to be smart? Which is most helpful to most people? When is it the better choice to care about yourself instead of those around you?
Suppose giving your last $5 to a homeless guy on the street meant saving him from a miserable, hungry night. That's compassion, right? However, suppose that $5 would have bought your train ticket to a fundraiser where you would have raised 200 times that much money and could have helped 200 more people. That's stupidity. ... Right?
I don't know. The problem with that situation is that it doesn't exist. What does exist is the man on the street with the small child asking for help. And frankly, even if he was lying about whatever situation he was supposedly in, he still somehow needed something, and maybe I could have helped him.
Anyway, just some thoughts to chew on. Hope everyone's week went well. Looking forward to future posts! Don't forget I've promised to answer any questions about myself you want to ask, so ask away!
DFTBA,
Emily